New Horizons Counseling Center Case Study

counseling claims management case study

This counseling claims management case study shows how Apna MBC cut New Horizons Counseling Center’s average time from visit to claim submission from 12 days to 2 and raised monthly collections by $40,500 in six months, with the same 10 clinicians and the same caseload.

New Horizons Counseling Center

Practice Snapshot

DetailNew Horizons Counseling Center
Practice typeOutpatient counseling group
Clinicians10 (5 LPCs, 3 LCSWs, 2 LMFTs)
LocationNorth Carolina
Apna MBC serviceClaims management
Primary challengeClaim processing backlogs
Engagement length6 months
Monthly chargesAbout $150,000 (unchanged during the engagement)
Monthly claim volumeAbout 1,150 claims

Headline Results

MeasureBeforeAfter
Days from visit to claim submission122
Monthly collections$84,000$124,500
Collections gained per monthn/a+$40,500
Unsubmitted claims at month end46022

Key Takeaways

  • Claims were reaching payers an average of 12 days after the visit. After six months that was 2 days, and 96% of claims went out within 2 business days (up from 33%).
  • Monthly collections rose from $84,000 to $124,500 on the same $150,000 of charges. That is $40,500 more per month, or about $486,000 a year.
  • The clearinghouse rejection rate fell from 14% to 3%. Most of the drop came from fixing subscriber, demographic and provider details before submission.
  • Days from visit to payment fell from 63 to 34, and claims lost to filing limits fell from 11 a month to 0.

Why New Horizons’ Claims Were Piling Up Unsent

New Horizons was seeing about 1,150 insurance claims a month with a front desk of two people who also handled check-in, calls and scheduling. Claim work got done when time allowed, and a claim processing backlog built up. By the time Apna MBC started, 460 claims worth $59,800 were sitting unsubmitted at month end, and some were close to payer filing deadlines.

Charge entry waited on clinicians

Charges were only entered once a clinician finished their notes and sent a superbill. Notes often came days later, so the average visit took 12 days to reach a payer. Nothing prompted anyone when a visit had no charge yet.

Rejected claims were not tracked

About 14% of claims (roughly 161 a month) bounced at the clearinghouse before reaching the payer. Rejections were read from a report only when someone had time. Only 29% were fixed and resubmitted within 2 business days, and 37 a month were never resubmitted at all.

Clinician and payer details were not matched before submission

Many rejections traced back to details that could have been checked earlier: subscriber and date of birth mismatches, rendering and billing provider NPI and taxonomy errors (including clinicians working under a supervisor’s license), and missing diagnosis or authorization details. Eleven claims a month aged past payer filing limits and could not be recovered.

How Apna MBC Streamlined New Horizons’ Claim Submission

This counseling claims management case study followed one rule: no claim should wait on someone remembering it. Apna MBC took over the claim cycle as part of its mental health billing services, working in four stages.

Stage 1: Backlog triage

We listed every unsubmitted and rejected claim and sorted it by payer, visit date and filing deadline. Claims closest to their deadline went out first, so no more were lost to timely filing.

Stage 2: Same-day charge capture and front-end checks

Charges were captured from the schedule on the day of the visit, with clinician notes completed against a short list of open items instead of waiting for superbills. Eligibility was checked through 270/271 transactions before sessions, and we built a payer enrollment matrix showing which clinician (including those billing under a supervisor) is credentialed with which payer.

Stage 3: Claim scrubbing and daily submission

Every claim was scrubbed for subscriber details, provider NPI and taxonomy, diagnosis, authorization, code, modifier and place of service before leaving. Insurance claim submission for counselors then ran daily, with clean claims going out as 837P files. We reviewed 277CA acknowledgements every day and fixed rejections within 2 business days.

Stage 4: Reporting and review

A weekly report listed unsubmitted claims, rejections and anything near a filing deadline. A monthly review covered five measures: days to submission, rejection rate, rejections fixed in 2 business days, unsubmitted claims and collections.

The daily claim submission routine

StepStandard
Charges capturedSame day as the visit
Eligibility checkedBefore the session
Claims scrubbedBefore submission
Claims submittedWithin 2 business days of the visit
Acknowledgements reviewedEvery business day
Rejections fixed and resubmittedWithin 2 business days

Engagement Timeline

  1. Weeks 1 to 3: Backlog triage by payer, visit date and filing deadline. The oldest and most time-sensitive claims were submitted first.
  2. Weeks 3 to 6: Same-day charge capture started, eligibility checks began before sessions, and the payer enrollment matrix was completed.
  3. Months 2 to 3: Claim scrubbing and daily 837P submission went live. 277CA acknowledgements were reviewed daily and rejections fixed within 2 business days.
  4. Months 4 to 6: Weekly reports and the monthly five-measure review ran as routine, and the remaining rejection causes were worked down.

Counseling Claims Management Case Study Results After Six Months

Claims reached payers 10 days sooner, far fewer bounced, and collections rose 48% on the same charges. Monthly figures, before Apna MBC and in month six:

MeasureBeforeAfterChange
Days from visit to claim submission122-10 days
Claims submitted within 2 business days33%96%+63 pts
Unsubmitted claims at month end46022-438
Value of unsubmitted charges$59,800$2,860-$56,940
Clearinghouse rejection rate14%3%-11 pts
Rejections fixed within 2 business days29%98%+69 pts
Rejected claims never resubmitted (per month)371-36
Claims lost to filing limits (per month)110-11
Days from visit to payment6334-29 days
Monthly collections$84,000$124,500+$40,500
Collections as share of charges56.0%83.0%+27.0 pts
Front desk hours on claims per weekAbout 24About 6-18 hours

Rejections by reason (per month)

ReasonBeforeAfterChange
Subscriber or demographic mismatch588-86%
Rendering or billing provider NPI or taxonomy419-78%
Missing or invalid diagnosis or authorization277-74%
Invalid code, modifier or place of service246-75%
Other115-55%
Total16135-78%

Of the 126 fewer rejections a month, 82 (65%) came from subscriber and provider fixes made before submission.

Annualized, the $40,500 monthly gain is about $486,000. That figure excludes the one-time recovery from clearing the original backlog.

Why It Worked

Submitting earlier and fixing problems at the front end did more than chasing rejections after the fact. The practice kept the same 10 clinicians and the same $150,000 of monthly charges, so the gain came from claims that were previously late, rejected or never sent.

  • Speed removed lost revenue. With claims out inside 2 business days, filing-limit losses dropped from 11 a month to 0, and the unsubmitted pile shrank from 460 claims to 22.
  • Front-end checks prevented most rejections. Subscriber, demographic and provider fixes accounted for 82 of the 126 fewer rejections a month.
  • Daily review closed the loop. Rejections fixed within 2 business days rose from 29% to 98%, so few claims stalled.
  • Staff time moved back to patients. Front desk time on claims fell from about 24 to about 6 hours a week.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is claims management for a counseling practice?

Claims management covers everything between the visit and the payer: capturing the charge, checking eligibility, scrubbing the claim, submitting it, and fixing rejections. For counselors it also means matching each clinician, including associate-licensed ones, to the payers they are enrolled with.

What causes a claim processing backlog?

The usual causes are late clinician notes, charges entered only when staff have time, no daily check of clearinghouse reports, and rejections that nobody owns. At New Horizons all four were present.

What is the difference between a rejection and a denial?

A rejection is a claim the clearinghouse or payer refuses before it is accepted for processing, usually because of a data error. A denial is a claim the payer accepted and then declined to pay. Rejections can be corrected and resubmitted, and a rejected claim that is never resubmitted earns nothing.

How long does it take to clear a claim backlog?

In this counseling claims management case study, the original backlog was triaged in the first three weeks, with the oldest and most deadline-sensitive claims going first. Daily submission was live by month three. Timing depends on backlog size and payer filing limits.

How can my practice get a claims review?

Call Apna MBC at (786) 475-5468 or use the contact form. We will review your unsubmitted and rejected claims and tell you where they are stuck.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn