Summit Psychiatry Group Case Study

psychiatry medical billing case study

This psychiatry medical billing case study shows how Apna MBC cut Summit Psychiatry Group’s coding and documentation errors from 31% of audited visits to 6% and raised monthly collections by $44,900 in six months, with the same six providers and the same caseload.

Template note: the practice name and every figure are illustrative placeholders. Replace them with client-approved, verified data before publishing. The second tab holds the Rank Math SEO setup, the image plan, and the placeholder list.

Practice snapshot

ItemDetail
PracticeSummit Psychiatry Group
IndustryPsychiatry
Providers6: 4 psychiatrists and 2 psychiatric nurse practitioners
LocationIllinois
ServiceMedical billing, with coding and documentation review
Primary challengeCoding and documentation errors
EngagementBegan May 2026, results measured over 6 months

Headline results

StatBeforeAfter
Audited visits with a coding or documentation error31%6%
Monthly collections$99,100$144,000
Additional collections per month+$44,900
First-pass claim acceptance79%96%

Key takeaways

  • Coding and documentation errors in audited visits fell from 31% to 6%, and first-pass claim acceptance rose from 79% to 96%.
  • Denied claims fell from about 147 a month to about 42, and coding and documentation denials made up 86 of the 105 fewer denials.
  • Monthly collections rose by $44,900 while monthly charges rose only 2.0%, from net evaluation and management level corrections.
  • Corrections went both ways. Visits billed above what the note supported were lowered.

Why Summit’s Claims Were Inaccurate Before They Were Sent

Summit billed about $168,000 a month across roughly 700 claims and collected $99,100 of it. Payers denied 21% of claims, about 147 a month. Most of the denials traced back to the claim itself: the codes did not match the note, or the note did not support the codes. A baseline audit of 300 encounters from the prior quarter found at least one coding or documentation error in 93 of them, or 31%.

Visit levels and add-on codes did not match the note

Providers chose an evaluation and management (E/M) level at checkout, and the level followed habit more than the note. Some visits were billed one level below what the documentation supported, and a few were billed above it. Psychotherapy add-on codes 90833, 90836, and 90838 were billed without psychotherapy time documented separately from the E/M time. The interactive complexity add-on, 90785, was sometimes attached to an E/M visit alone.

Notes did not give payers what they look for

Notes often stated total visit time but not the psychotherapy portion. Many used an unspecified diagnosis such as F32.9 (major depressive disorder, single episode, unspecified) when the note described the episode and severity. Telehealth visits did not always record the modality or where the patient and provider were located. Only 64% of notes met the documentation checklist that Apna MBC later built with Summit.

The payer found the errors, not the practice

Summit had no review before claims went out. Errors surfaced as denials, mostly for a code and modifier mismatch, a diagnosis that did not fit the procedure, missing information, or medical necessity. Payers also asked for records on about 14 submitted claims a month, which held payment while staff searched for notes.

How Apna MBC Improved Summit’s Claim Accuracy

Apna MBC works inside the practice management system a client already uses, so Summit did not migrate or retrain on new software. The work in this psychiatry medical billing case study followed four stages, with accuracy checked before each claim was sent. These are the same steps behind our mental health billing services.

Stage 1: Coding and documentation baseline audit

We reviewed 300 encounters across all six providers. Each was scored against the payer’s rules and a documentation checklist, and each error was grouped by type. This gave Summit a measured error rate and a ranked list of what to fix first.

Stage 2: A psychiatry rule sheet and note checklist

We built a one-page rule sheet for Summit’s most common services and a short checklist for each note.

ServiceCodeWhat the note must show
Medication management visit99212 to 99215The level is supported by medical decision making or total time on the date of the encounter, and the note says which was used
Psychotherapy with an E/M visitAdd-on 90833, 90836, 90838Psychotherapy time stated separately from E/M time: 16 to 37 minutes for 90833, 38 to 52 for 90836, and 53 or more for 90838
Interactive complexity90785The qualifying factor is documented, and the add-on is reported only with a service that allows it, never with an E/M visit alone
Psychiatric diagnostic evaluation90792Medical services are documented alongside the evaluation. Use 90791 when there are none
Telehealth visitModifier 95 and place of serviceModality, patient location, and provider location are recorded, and each payer’s rule is applied
DiagnosisICD-10-CMThe most specific code the note supports, including episode, severity, and remission status

Stage 3: Review every claim before it is sent

Our coders compared the codes on each claim with the visit note before submission. When the note and the code did not match, we sent the provider a short, non-leading question and waited for the answer before billing. Corrections went both ways: levels were raised when the note supported more, and lowered when it supported less.

Stage 4: Provider feedback and monthly tracking

Each provider received a one-page monthly summary of the errors found in their notes. We re-audited a sample of 100 encounters a month and tracked payer record requests. Summit’s administrator received the results with the five core billing measures.

Engagement Timeline

  1. Weeks 1 to 2, baseline audit: 300 encounters reviewed and errors grouped by type.
  2. Weeks 3 to 4, rule sheet and checklist: built with Summit and walked through with every provider.
  3. Months 2 to 3, pre-bill review live: every claim checked against its note before submission.
  4. Months 4 to 6, feedback and re-audit: monthly provider summaries sent and a 100-encounter sample audited each month.

Psychiatry Medical Billing Case Study Results After Six Months

Summit’s audited error rate fell from 31% to 6%, and monthly collections rose from $99,100 to $144,000, while claim volume and the provider team stayed the same. Figures are for the sixth month of the engagement.

MetricBeforeAfterChange
Monthly charges$168,000$171,400+$3,400 (+2.0%)
Monthly claims submittedAbout 700About 700No change
Monthly collections$99,100$144,000+$44,900
Gross collection rate59.0%84.0%+25.0 points
Audited visits with a coding or documentation error31%6%-25 points
First-pass claim acceptance79%96%+17 points
Claim denial rate21%6%-15 points
Denied claims per month14742-105 (-71%)
Visit notes meeting the documentation checklist64%95%+31 points
Payer record requests per month143-11
Average days from submission to payment46 days31 days-15 days

Denied claims per month, by reason:

Denial reasonBeforeAfterChange
Coding or modifier error (CARC 4, 11)6512-82%
Documentation or medical necessity (CARC 16, 50)418-80%
Eligibility or authorization (CARC 27, 197)2513-48%
Duplicate, filing limit, other169-44%
Total14742-71%

Claims corrected by pre-bill review, average per month after review began (none were reviewed before):

CorrectionClaims per month
E/M level too low, raised to match the note34
E/M level too high, lowered to match the note7
Psychotherapy add-on time did not match the note29
Interactive complexity add-on without a qualifying service12
Diagnosis code not specific enough for the note24
Telehealth place of service or modifier12
Total corrected before submission (17% of claims)118

$538,800 a year in added collections. This is the $44,900 monthly gain multiplied by twelve. It assumes the sixth-month rate holds and volume stays level, and it includes the 2.0% rise in charges from E/M level corrections.

Why Fixing Claims Before They Were Sent Beat Fixing Them After Denial

Summit billed about 700 claims a month before and after, with the same six providers. Charges rose 2.0% because net E/M level corrections added $3,400 a month. The rest of the $44,900 gain came from fewer denials and cleaner claims.

Coding and documentation denials fell from 106 to 20 a month. That is 86 of the 105 fewer denials, or 82%. These are errors that originate in the visit, so they are cheapest to fix before the claim is sent. Eligibility, authorization, and other denials fell by 19, which accounts for the remainder.

The notes changed as well. Notes meeting the documentation checklist rose from 64% to 95%, and payer record requests fell from 14 to 3 a month, which means less held payment and less staff time spent searching for records. E/M level and psychotherapy add-on time remain the two most common corrections, so the monthly provider summaries continue to focus on them.

Corrections went both ways. Seven E/M visits a month were lowered because the note supported a lower level. The aim of the review is claims that match the record, not higher codes.

Questions About This Case Study

What is a coding and documentation review in psychiatric billing?

It compares the codes on each claim with the visit note before the claim is sent. It checks that the E/M level, any psychotherapy add-on, the diagnosis, and any telehealth details are supported by what the provider documented. Errors are corrected or queried first, so the payer does not find them.

Why do psychiatry claims get denied for coding errors?

Common causes are an E/M level that does not match the note, a psychotherapy add-on without separately documented psychotherapy time, an add-on attached to a service that does not allow it, a diagnosis that is too general for the procedure, and telehealth details that do not meet the payer’s rule. Summit’s audit found all five.

How is the E/M level chosen for a psychiatry visit?

The level is based on the medical decision making or on total time on the date of the encounter, and the note should show which was used. When a psychotherapy add-on is billed with the visit, the psychotherapy time is documented separately and is not counted again toward the E/M. Check the current CPT guidelines and each payer’s policy.

How long did it take Summit to see results?

In this psychiatry medical billing case study, the error rate fell fastest in the first three months, once the rule sheet and pre-bill review were in place. Denials and record requests continued to fall as provider feedback took effect. The results table shows the sixth-month figures.

How can my practice get a coding and documentation review?

Call (786) 475-5468 or use the contact form. We start by auditing a sample of your recent visits against their notes. We scope an engagement only if we find revenue we can recover or errors that put claims at risk.

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn